A Misnából az jön ki, hogy elvileg ma is kellene fújnunk, ahol van bét din.
(Nem Rabbi Elázárt követjük, aki dáát jáchid.)
With regard to the Festival day of Rosh HaShana that occurs on Shabbat, in the Temple they would sound the shofar as usual. However, they would not sound it in the rest of the country outside the Temple. After the Temple was destroyed, Rabban Yoḥanan ben Zakkai instituted that the people should sound the shofar on Shabbat in every place where there is a court of twenty-three judges. Rabbi Elazar said: Rabban Yoḥanan ben Zakkai instituted this practice only in Yavne, where the Great Sanhedrin of seventy-one judges resided in his time, but nowhere else. They said to him: He instituted the practice both in Yavne and in any place where there is a court. The mishna adds: And Jerusalem in earlier times had this additional superiority over Yavne after Rabban Yoḥanan ben Zakkai instituted this practice, for in any city whose residents could see Jerusalem and hear the sounding of the shofar from there, and which was near to Jerusalem and people could come to Jerusalem from there, they would sound the shofar there as well, as it was considered part of Jerusalem. But in Yavne they would sound the shofaronly in the court itself, not in the surrounding cities.
MISHNA: With regard to the Festival day of Rosh HaShana that occurs on Shabbat, in the Temple they would sound the shofar as usual. However, they would not sound it in the rest of the country outside the Temple. After the Temple was destroyed, Rabban Yoḥanan ben Zakkai instituted that the people should sound the shofar on Shabbat in every place where there is a court of twenty-three judges. Rabbi Elazar said: Rabban Yoḥanan ben Zakkai instituted this practice only in Yavne, where the Great Sanhedrin of seventy-one judges resided in his time, but nowhere else. They said to him: He instituted the practice both in Yavne and in any place where there is a court.
A Szfát Emet kérdése: hogyan vezethette be Rábán Jochánán ben Zákáj (chochmá, minján)?
Válasza: rácon cháchámim volt, hogy ne bitulozódjon teljesen.
Talán Toszfot miatt, aki gyönyörű chilukot talál sófár és luláv között: az egyiknek nagyon mefurás a táámja, a másiknak direkt elrejtik (ld. Szuká 38a / R Acha bar Jáákovot direkt elhallgatattják).
...
Rámbám szerint ma azért nem fújunk, mert nincsen szmichá. (A Szfát Emet logikája szerint ez nehéz.)
At present, while the Temple is destroyed, wherever a court whose judges received semichah in Eretz Yisrael permanently holds sessions, the shofar is sounded on the Sabbath. Furthermore, the shofar is sounded on the Sabbath only in a court that has sanctified the new moon. However, the shofar will not be sounded in other courts, even though their judges have received semichah. Also, the shofar is sounded only in the presence of a high court.
It may be sounded during the entire time they are in session. Even after they have begun preparing to rise - as long as they have not risen - the shofar may be sounded before them. However, outside the court, the shofar may not be sounded.
Why is the shofar allowed to be sounded in the court? Because the court is scrupulous [in the observance of the mitzvot] and, in its presence, those who blow the shofar will not carry the shofar in the public domain, for the court will warn the people and inform them.
A Rif (Rámbám apjának tanítójának (Ri Migás) a tanítója) fújt, de ez látszólag a részéről forradalmi volt, és nem is fogadták el.
Tur: a többség szerint 23 tagú BD kell.
Alternatív patent: közepesen kiskorúra bízni (de mit érünk vele? Nem mechujáv – Szabó Tamás).
...
Rán kérdése: brisz vs. sófár.
...
BJ hoz még egy lehetséges kifogást: BD kávuá kell (még ha nem is kell, hogy 23 tagú vagy számuch legyen).
Rif tálmidjai sem merték őt követni.
...