Tefilá / praktikus kérdések (alvó, kiskorú ámen, összelátás)

·6 views
שולחן ערוך, אורח חיים נ״ה:ו׳

If one of the 10 started to pray by himself and [was in a part of the prayers where he] could not answer with them or he was sleeping, even here (ie. in this scenario), he is included with them.

Itt érdekes összehasonlítás arról, aki még imádkozik: https://ph.yhb.org.il/en/02-02-07/

משנה ברורה נ״ה:ל״ג

...

ביאור הלכה נ״ה:ו׳:א׳

...

פסחים פ״ה ב:ז׳

GEMARA:Rav Yehuda said that Rav said: And the halakha is similar with regard to prayer, in that one who is standing outside the doorway cannot be included together with those praying inside. The Gemara notes that Rav disagrees with Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi, as Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi said: Even a barrier of iron does not separate between the Jewish people and their Father in Heaven. Barriers are irrelevant with regard to prayer.

רש"י על פסחים פ״ה ב:ז׳:א׳

...

תוספות על פסחים פ״ה ב:ז׳:א׳

...

Hosszan foglalkozik ilyen kérdésekkel:

שולחן ערוך, אורח חיים נ״ה:י״ג

All of the 10 need to be in one place and the prayer leader with them. And one who stands inside the doorway, [in the area of the doorway that is] from the door-stop and outward... meaning [the area] that when you close the door at the place of the inner [lip] of the thickness of the door and outwards - it is like [he is] outside.

שולחן ערוך, אורח חיים נ״ה:י״ח

If some of the ten [men] are in the synagogue and some of them are in the courtyard, they do not join with each other.

שולחן ערוך, אורח חיים רט״ו:ב׳

If one hears a fellow Jew reciting one of the blessings — even if he did not hear the entire blessing from beginning to end, and even if he himself is not obligated in that blessing — he is required to respond "Amen" after it. However, if the one reciting the blessing was a heretic, or a Samaritan, or a young child, or an adult who altered the established wording of the blessings, one does not respond "Amen" after him. Rema: One may respond "Amen" after a non-Jew if he heard the entire blessing from his mouth (Rabbenu Yitzchak, chapter Eilu Devarim).

שולחן ערוך, אורח חיים רט״ו:ג׳

The rule that one does not respond "Amen" after a child applies specifically when the child is learning the blessings from his teacher, for it is permitted to teach children the blessings in their proper form even though, during the learning, they are reciting the blessings in vain. However, when the children are reciting the blessings to fulfill their own obligation — since they are of an age of education (bnei chinuch) — one does respond "Amen" after them. The same applies when they recite the haftarah in the synagogue.

ברכות נ״ג ב:ל׳
Shmuel raised a dilemma before Rav: What is the halakha with regard to answering amen after the blessings of schoolchildren? Rav said to him: One answers amen following everyone whom we hear recite a blessing, except for schoolchildren, as they recite blessings merely in order to learn them, not as expressions of thanksgiving. This applies specifically at a time when they are not fulfilling their obligation with the recitation of the blessing, but are simply learning. However, at a time when they are fulfilling their obligation through the recitation of a blessing, one answers amen after their blessing.